Stolen Identities, Stolen Cars: Auto Loan Fraud Hits New Heights in 2025

Back To Fraud Alert Center

A Moneywise report citing FTC data reveals a shocking 71% increase in auto loan or lease fraud reports in just the first five months of 2025 — outpacing all previous years.

The victims? Everyday Americans who often don’t realize their identities have been stolen until it's too late — when the bills start arriving for cars they never purchased or drove.

🚨 How the Fraudsters Operated

Thieves are increasingly using real, stolen identities — sometimes bought off the dark web or harvested through phishing — to apply for auto loans. These applications often pass through the system undetected because the identity appears legitimate.

Some are also leveraging synthetic identities, which combine real and fake information to create credit-worthy personas. Once approved, the fraudsters vanish with the car, leaving the real individual — or the lender — stuck with the loss.

🔴 What Red Flags Were Missed

Lenders and dealers often rely on credit score and payment history, not real-time identity verification, to make prequalification decisions.
Many fraudsters use drop addresses or fake employers, but if no one verifies the applicant’s identity early, it sails through.
Victims often don’t know what hit them until they see a delinquency on their credit report or receive a collections notice.

💰 Who Paid the Price

Victims of identity theft face months — sometimes years — of credit repair.
Lenders and dealers take massive charge-offs.
The system itself loses integrity, and trust in digital finance erodes.

🛡️ What Could Have Stopped It

Stronger identity verification before credit prequalification could have made a significant difference.

That’s where tools like VeriQual™ come in — verifying an applicant’s identity before their credit is pulled or a loan is originated. If the person can’t be verified, the process stops right there.

📣 Final Thought

Auto loan fraud is evolving fast — and the cost to consumers and lenders is rising with it. As identity theft tactics become more sophisticated, fraud prevention must begin at the very first step of the financing process.

Look for the VeriQual™ badge when getting prequalified for financing — it’s your first line of defense against auto loan fraud.